Have you looked at ataraxion? It's a medium paced game that's very backtag friendly and has lots of plot stuff to keep things from getting too Slice of Lifey. We have a great TVD/The Originals cast with Damon, Stefan, Caroline, Tyler (that's me!), Bonnie, Hayley, Elijah, Klaus and Rebekah and we would love to see Jeremy get thrown into the mix.