HELLO I don't know what your stance on AUs is, but since I saw your post here I figured I'd drop you a line to point out capitalh. Capital H is a superhero based AU game set in Los Angeles, and can accommodate pretty much any sort of character who would fit into a comic book environment with as little or as much AUing as you'd like.

Presently we do have a troll cast of about four character (of which I play Sollux Captor), and the in game world has been built so that historically Earth has been at war with Alternia, and so most of the troll characters ended up there while trying to escape their fates on Alternia. There is some weird Ancestor stuff happening too, but that's another story.

And if you didn't like it for Aradia, with it being a superhero game it could also work quite nicely for someone from Umbrella Academy. Or both! AC is set up so that you only have to do AC for half your characters - since it's such a big world, it makes it easier to get into plots if you have a variety, and not all characters are expected to be kept active simultaneously. Multiple characters definitely isn't necessary though.

It is also one of the most backtaggy games I've ever played in, to be quite honest.

ANYWAY, happy hunting!